The Holy Land Justice and Peace Commission Denounces the Manipulation of the “Just War” Argument in Gaza
The Justice and Peace Commission of the Holy Land has taken a stand against the misuse of the concept of a “just war” in the ongoing conflict in Gaza. In a powerful statement, the commission rebukes political leaders who are using the term to justify the destructive actions that have resulted in the loss of civilian lives.
By Lisa Zengarini
Referring to the longstanding teachings of the Catholic Church on the principles of a just war as outlined in the Catholic Catechism, the Commission firmly rejects the notion that the current situation in Gaza meets the criteria for a just war. The indiscriminate killing of civilians in response to recent Hamas attacks does not align with the principles of justice and peace.
Neither Hamas’ attacks nor Israel’s indiscriminate response are a ‘just war’
The Commission emphasizes that neither the actions of Hamas nor the devastating response from Israel can be classified as a just war according to Catholic Doctrine. The failure to distinguish between combatants and civilians, as well as the disproportionate use of force, has resulted in tragic consequences for innocent lives on both sides.
The Commission challenges the argument that sacrificing Palestinian lives now will save Israeli lives in the future, pointing out that such reasoning disregards the value of human life in the present moment.
“The manipulation of the language of just war theory is not only about words: it is having tangible, fatal results.”
Principles of distinction and proportionality not respected
According to Catholic Doctrine, just wars must uphold the principles of distinction and proportionality. The failure to adhere to these principles in the current conflict has led to an alarming number of civilian casualties, particularly among women and children.
The Commission stresses the importance of upholding international humanitarian law and calls for a ceasefire to prevent further loss of life. Pope Francis’ appeals for peace and justice resonate strongly in this context, urging all parties to focus on resolving the conflict through dialogue and compassion.
In conclusion, the Commission echoes the Church’s plea for peace and justice for all in the Holy Land, emphasizing the urgent need to end the conflict and prevent the spread of violence. By embracing a language of peace and reconciliation, a new path forward can be forged towards a brighter future for all inhabitants of the Holy Land.
